
First meeting of study group this afternoon at animal-friendly café in Leith. Impressed by participants' efforts: Saussure, although not Masters student invited because of academic approach to any topic, had already prepared notes to guide discussion. Cindy arrived with small whiteboard for brainstorming, Maya brought cookies and Véronique had found functioning tape recorder in skip. Oscar arrived with stenograph for taking notes. Tricky moment when café manager patiently explained that basket hired for afternoon only big enough for 6 cat-sized animals and Oscar much larger than cat and important to comply with health and safety regulations. Oscar, with usual impeccable manners persuaded him most of time wouldn't be in basket, then charmed him by showing how stenograph works and describing in great detail car boot sale where he purchased machine. Manager - himself devotee of car boot sales - so impressed by Oscar's diligence, immediately attached clipboard to wall, and asked other customers to keep noise down during important meeting. Pleased to observe immediate hush and ambience of respect for learned animals.

Began by listing technical words we don't understand: postmodernism, poststructuralism, deconstruction.
Decided to analyse postmodernism and poststructuralism together as both begin with post. Brainstormed 'post'. Letters, parcels, posts to support plants, post as in work. Not so easy to brainstorm structuralism. Oscar had dictionary definition: any theory that embodies structural principles. Then Cindy suggested finding definition for poststructuralism:
an approach to literature that, proceeding from the tenets of structuralism, maintains that, as words have no absolute meaning, any text is open to an unlimited range of interpretations.
Stared at each other. Maya pointed out that any poststructuralist writing was waste of time - if it had unlimited range of interpretations why bother to write?. Obviously delighted by philosophical approach, she pointed out that no need to read either. Enough Just to wander around thinking anything you want. Exhausted by contribution to study afternoon, she ate ten cookies and then declared she felt a bit sick.


As we pondered this erudite thought, Henri wandered in clutching a hessian sack which, he informed us, contained a week's worth of fan letters. Immediately, Oscar sprang up and told him he could join us, but only if he didn't distract us from important task. Henri, puffed up with success of writing Christmas message on police cards, omitting important vowels and consonants suggested we use lateral thinking approach to understanding term 'poststructuralism' and remove several letters to see where that got us.


Puzzled looks exchanged. Henri took whiteboard marker and rubbed out four letters. Left with More puzzled expressions. Oscar grabbed whiteboard pen and turned to Henri:
'You might be able to impress Headquarters of Lothian and Borders Police station by Christmas card messages with missing consonants and vowels, but you can't apply that to literary theory. You shouldn't turn up to group unless prepared to take things seriously.'
'Get a life,' Henri said, and picked up his sack with such force it burst open and paper spilt out. 'It's letters from appreciate customers.'
Cindy and Véronique examined bits of paper. 'There's nothing written,' they said in chorus.
Henri looked embarrassed. 'Brought wrong sack.'
'You're a fraud,' Maya said.
'If I'm not appreciated here, I'm going home to study recipes for stuffed vine leaves,' Henri said, with attempt at dignity.
After he left, Oscar tried to get group back on track but atmosphere killed. Agreed to finish there, but each of us to find definition of 'post-modernism' for next time. Also agreed to change afternoon of meeting so that Henri couldn't spoil it again.

Felt bad when got home, however. Didn't like seeing Henri humiliated, even if he's become puffed-up. Henri good friend at start of Masters. Now seems Oscar trying to stir things up between him and me. Must remain loyal to all friends. Also think Oscar might be control freak. Hard to draw line between good management and taking over. Might get advice from Saussure about handling difficult situation.

Purrs Bakhtin





























